Pro-Democracy Resolution as adopted by Pittsburgh City Council 09/15/2009

City of Pittsburgh
Legislative File Number 2009-1777 (version 1)
..Body
Whereas: Peaceful political expression is a fundamental right protected under the United
States and Pennsylvania Constitutions, and the free exercise of the First Amendment rights of
speech, association and assembly and enforcement of Fourth Amendment rights against unlawful
search and seizure is essential for residents of and visitors to the City of Pittsburgh; and
Whereas: The City of Pittsburgh has consistently fostered a long tradition that celebrates
robust public discussion of issues, including the unfettered expression of opinion at public
demonstrations; and
Whereas: Recent demonstrators at large political events in other cities have been
undermined by questionable police practices and violations of civil liberties; and
Whereas: In September, 2009, the International Coal Conference and the G20 Summit will
draw a broad group of citizens, residents and visitors with differing viewpoints and opinions to
engage in various forms of democratic public expression in Pittsburgh; and
Whereas: The Pittsburgh City Council believes there is no inherent conflict between the
City's duties to secure public safety and also to protect constitutionally guaranteed political
activity;
..Title
Therefore be it resolved: That the Pittsburgh City Council calls upon the City to promote
successful high profile events by ensuring:
1. reasonable and prompt action on permit applications for public demonstrations
during the events;
2. that decision-making authority for policing public demonstrations remains under
the leadership and jurisdiction of local authorities to the greatest extent possible;
3. appropriate training in Constitutional Rights for those policing public
demonstrations;
4. access to as well as freedom of movement at public demonstrations;
5. that public demonstrations can take place within sight and sound of the object of
the protest;
6. barricades of “protest pens” to confine movement at demonstrations are not used
unless absolutely necessary;
7. the dispersal of public assemblages only in the event of an emergency and with the
provision of clear orders with reasonable time guidelines; and
8. complete and timely disclosure of information regarding the location and
condition of arrestees, including to legal support personnel granted timely access
to work with the demonstrators; and
Be it further resolved, that the Pittsburgh City Council calls upon the City to promote a
successful public discourse around high profile events by refraining from:
1. use of questionable legal practices, including arrest without just cause, use of preemptive
arrests, excessive bail, or malicious prosecution of participants engaging
in public political expression;
2. use of unnecessary force - including the use of projectile, chemical electronic,
experimental or other so-called 'less lethal' weapons - in policing public
demonstrations except as absolutely necessitated by legitimate law-enforcement
purposes;
3. the use of any force on unarmed, non-violence demonstrators;
4. the use of force purely as a form of intimidation or as a threat of physical harm to
gain compliance, including unconstitutional forced dispersal of lawful protest;
5. the use of 'less-lethal' weapons in any way that contradicts manufacturers'
instructions;
6. the surveillance, intimidation or harassment of groups planning non-violent,
protected forms of public expression, including the harassment of demonstration
organizers, disruption to places of assembly, and the destruction of protest
materials; and
7. the deliberate distortion of information given to the media or the public, regarding
protesters intent, the circumstances of arrest, or the actions of police.
And be it further resolved, that the Pittsburgh City Council acknowledges the serious
responsibility of the City of Pittsburgh to continue the City's long tradition upholding the free
exercise of First and Fourth Amendment right while protecting both public safety and
constitutionally guaranteed civil liberties for all parties during the upcoming high profile, high
security events.

Permalink